Trump’s meltdown and Kamala’s upsurge | The Coffee Klatch with Robert Reich
Robert Reich
759K subscribers
Aug 17, 2024
The Coffee Klatch with Robert Reich
On Thursday, Trump was supposed to have had a press conference on the economy. Instead, it turned into another one of his rambling, incoherent rants against Kamala. On Friday, Kamala pointed the way to a new economy. Trump continues to melt down; she continues to surge upward.
Today Heather and I compare Kamalanomics and its focus on corporate power with the garbage economics Trump is peddling — at least when he’s not attacking Kamala — including his bonkers idea to eliminate taxes on Social Security.
Please grab a cup, pull up a stool, and join us. Also, please take our poll.
Transcript
- 0:01
- and it is the Saturday coffee clutch
- with Heather loft house and yours truly
- Robert R and Heather what do we have
- anything happened this week nothing for
- usual and nothing next week either oh
- well I disagree let's talk about K's
- upsurge Trump's submerge how about you
- like that how about trumponomics and
- kinomics lots to discuss on their
- alleged policies and then how about the
- DNC what you're thinking about for next
- week
- let's go into it I I think that U you
- know this is an amazing phenomenon a lot
- of people say to me they've never and
- these are political you know insiders
- they've never seen anything like the
- turnaround in the The Fortunes of a
- party of a political party of a of a
- presidential race uh the Democrats are
- now surging the polls are showing that
- kamla Harris is actually running now
- neck and neck or ahead of Donald Trump
- in some critical swing States and what
- 1:02
- is Donald Trump
- doing panicking he's panicking he's
- melting down and rambling and incoherent
- uh I think he is actually caught in the
- headlights he doesn't know what to do uh
- and his handlers are you know on
- Thursday they had it was supposed to be
- a big Trump event about about the
- economy but he didn't want to make it
- about the economy he wanted to make it
- about kamla kamla and he likes to attack
- and he even was Defensive he said uh you
- know I don't I don't I don't I don't
- mind attacking in fact I have a right to
- attack I I can attack uh as if he was
- talking to his handlers who who said
- this is about the economy this is about
- policy this is not about you know you
- need to go after persuadables he doesn't
- know how to do that he doesn't have any
- I mean he's out of control he can't
- control himself and it turns out that in
- terms of the qualities I'm looking for a
- president of the United States to have
- 2:01
- self-control would be on the list well
- there it's not only lack of self-control
- and we know that from his first term but
- also confronted with a woman and a black
- woman uh is all it's as if it brings out
- in Trump all of his craziness even worse
- yeah I mean he is uh he doesn't know how
- to deal with it yeah it's a Comm nomenon
- as they're saying
- onomon is that said it right that's what
- the cool kids are saying these days well
- it's
- he's melting down and he's doing these
- press conferences is he going to I mean
- the counter programming he hasn't quite
- figured out what he's doing yet no and I
- this worries me a little bit because
- we're going and we're going to talk
- about the convention next week but uh
- they as we go into the Democratic
- Convention as as kamla Harris and uh
- wals continue to do better and better uh
- I
- think my fear looking at his behavior
- 3:01
- I'm talking about Trump is his tendency
- is to do something crazier more
- explosive more outrageous change the
- entire nature of the game I know I don't
- know what it is I don't either I don't
- want to know I don't even think I have
- the skills to strategize in that
- direction do all dire I don't want you
- to have those let's not play that game
- but in terms of one thing he's announc
- so he's all over the place except he
- will announce cutting Social Security
- cutting tax
- no no no no he doesn't forgive me this
- is but you were right you were right but
- what he has actually stated publicly is
- he wants to get her taxes get rid of
- federal taxes on Social Security yeah
- and U what is it actually going to do
- what it's actually going to do is it is
- number one it is going to destroy Social
- Security because those taxes are
- extraordinarily important for the trust
- fund and I can say this as a previous uh
- trust fund truste of the Social Security
- 4:01
- trust fund uh you need
- that that flow of money right now trust
- see uh the the Social Security is in
- danger of running out of money that the
- trustees say in
- 2033 and if Trump actually were to cut
- the Social Security taxes out uh that
- would Advance the time right uh of
- Social Security running out of money and
- importantly who does it hurt and who
- does it benefit
- well this particular plan in the short
- term uh benefits mostly High income
- Social Security beneficiaries uh but
- over the long term it would destroy
- Social Security Now Heather this is
- something the Republicans have been
- trying to do and wanting to do for years
- because Social Security is the most
- popular program in the entire federal
- government Franklin D Roosevelt put it
- into effect in
- 1935 and a lot of people then said to
- him well why should people have
- individual accounts and this is all kind
- 5:02
- of uh complicated and he said no if
- everybody has an individual Social
- Security account and they contribute
- into that account they feel that they
- are owed it and we will never see this
- program ended and he was right except
- for Donald Trump he didn't anticipate
- that Trump would take away Republicans
- would salute him and follow his orders
- so this is this is dangerous the easy
- response and what the Democrats are have
- already proposed Biden has proposed it I
- think KLA Harris ought to be even
- clearer about it is you take away the
- cap on income that is subject to the
- Social Security tax and right now that
- cap this year is
- about what is it
- 186,000 something like that it goes up
- uh adjusted for inflation every year uh
- but anybody who earns any more than that
- right is excused from paying Social
- 6:01
- Security taxes so it's a very regressive
- tax overall uh take the cap off or maybe
- set the cap so that it starts at 250,000
- or 400,000 it's more politically
- feasible we've talked about this let's
- move the cap up just just do that and
- you'll save Social Security and it and
- the rich will pay their fair share
- that's why Social Security is in trouble
- but instead so he's proposing this right
- this tax cut he claims it's a tax cut
- but it's going to hurt the poorest
- seniors 25% of their income is going to
- be cut and the richest are going to
- benefit from it I mean it's a classic
- and he's doing you know his spin where
- he says you're welcome everyone it's not
- everyone well he believes that the
- American public is incredibly gullible
- and unfortunately uh people are gullible
- to the extent that people some people
- say well yes take away Social Security
- taxes but it's just like his you know
- his
- 2017 tax cut which was trickle down
- 7:01
- nonsense nothing trickled down he say
- guaranteed $4,000 would trickle down to
- everybody four everybody would have
- $4,000 and nobody got $4,000 did you no
- I didn't but also I like that tweet you
- once did where it said trickle down
- economics and then it took the S off and
- then the C and then it went all the way
- down and it stopped with trick trick
- that's what happened it is a yeah but a
- $1.6 trillion
- cut I mean this is not this is ugly but
- but hopefully people realize it and
- decide maybe he's not the president for
- me after all well I think that maybe
- more and more people are realizing that
- uh I hope so and he doesn't deal in
- policy I mean the the interesting thing
- you say he doesn't he's not interested
- in policy he doesn't want to talk about
- policy uh but when he does come up with
- policies they are usually 180 degrees
- wrong they reward the rich big
- corporations and they penalty was the
- 8:00
- people who are average working people or
- the poor we could talk about this for
- days his tariffs that he's talking about
- I mean the few things he has spoken
- about the tariffs are an interesting
- example because he says let's charge
- foreigners uh for and foreign countries
- for selling their goods in the United
- States without even understanding that a
- tariff is paid by people who buy the
- goods people here in the United States
- you put up tariffs you know 30 40 50
- wants to go 100% what happens everything
- becomes more costly that that that it's
- not only hard and difficult and harmful
- for consumers in the United States but
- it also will aggravate inflation right
- and so then on the other hand we have
- kinomics she has been slowly but surely
- announcing some real policies some real
- plans some real Frameworks let's get
- into it this is actually very important
- uh and I didn't want to make this whole
- conversation about policy but it's
- important to understand these things she
- 9:00
- came out uh Thursday uh against price
- gouging uh in food now this is the this
- is something that is really big for a
- lot of people uh because even though
- inflation has come down toward the 2%
- Target that the FED set for inflation uh
- but a lot of people still are paying
- through the nose uh and food is one of
- those things that is inflation comes
- down but prices don't necessarily come
- down and why is that
- well you asked the great question and
- she's answering it it's because of
- concentration because these companies
- big companies have too much power food
- industry is a good example uh in fact uh
- beef is produced by four companies and
- when you get four companies producing
- 85% of beef processors beef Packers what
- does that mean it means that they can
- coordinate pricing they don't need to
- 10:01
- and they're not competitive in the sense
- that they have to reduce prices no they
- keep prices up and it's not just the
- beef it's the corn you know it's over
- when we're talking over 50 60 70% for
- these things the fertilizers I mean it's
- the entire food 7% of all the fertilizer
- four companies 80% of the Corn 69% of
- all grocery sales four companies and
- when you have those few they are
- coordinating they're not going to cut
- prices right so she's gonna come after
- this at multiple levels right and we
- don't know exactly we don't have the
- crystal clear plans but it seems like
- she's going to address it in numerous
- ways all of which are needed which and a
- lot of it has to do with giving more
- resources to the Federal Trade
- Commission to go after these monopolies
- and more resources more resources to the
- antitrust division of the justice
- department to get more resources uh you
- know speaking of that Kroger and
- Alberton now they wanted you're going to
- say they wanted to two of the biggest
- 11:02
- grocery chains in America they wanted to
- merge they wanted they are actively
- trying to merge uh and the government is
- saying no you can't merge and what did
- Kroger Kroger said well I'll tell you
- what we will reduce our prices by a
- billion dollars yeah if you allow us to
- merge come on it's like we can't lower
- our prices I mean we could lower our
- prices we can't really but only if you
- give us a little more power I mean it's
- pretty ridiculous to see this in a news
- article but here's a a gross admission
- by Kroger that they actually could
- reduce prices by a billion dollars I
- mean this is this if you wanted evidence
- that there is not enough competition in
- groceries here it is yeah or that power
- is skewed and they have it and and
- pricing power in fact if you look across
- the economy other uh the reason you have
- record levels of profits AC across the
- economy is not your mom and pop stores
- 12:02
- it's because big companies have
- concentrated more and more of their
- power they are merging they are growing
- uh they one of the biggest uh reasons
- for mergers now is pricing power of
- course up right I'm sure you saw Mars is
- trying to purchase Kell NOA for
- something like 38 billion and that would
- be the biggest merger of the year I mean
- we're talking they've already merged
- you've read the stats you've and then
- there's more happening yeah and and when
- you see and that's why it is so
- important to attack these monopolies uh
- it's it's disguised people don't know
- about Monopoly power because you don't
- see it behind all of these individual
- brand names you think oh I have there
- are dozens of brands on my super you
- know my Supermarket shelves but it turns
- out the brands behind the brands you
- have just three or four companies right
- and they are trying to merge and the
- Comm comma um Harris Tim Wall's plan
- 13:01
- includes a lot of things right so we're
- talking about trying to address housing
- issues and affordable housing again
- through various modalities trying to get
- at it um but it's interesting that price
- gouging around food and groceries was
- what I saw on the New York Times earlier
- this week as the lead it is and uh I
- think it's it's
- politically powerful it's the right
- thing to do uh it makes economic sense
- now obviously you know uh monopolies are
- not the only reason that we've had
- inflation uh but they are very big and
- very important and most people
- understand that uh if they think about
- it and they get the data they understand
- what's going on and it's a lever where
- we have some control yeah you know a lot
- of stuff as it relates to the economy
- and the macro issues are less easy to
- control exactly exactly we're talking
- about the structure of the economy uh
- and I think that uh Joe Biden made a
- 14:01
- very good the Biden Harris
- Administration made a very good
- beginning at going after uh all of these
- monopolization I mean uh you know look
- at
- uh both the Federal Trade Commission and
- the antitrust division uh have done very
- very good work with more resources they
- can do even more that's it okay I want
- to talk about the DNC that's coming up
- this week what are we thinking about it
- what's going to happen
- uh you were talking about the Democratic
- National Convention in Chicago 2024 well
- I think that uh it's going to be a
- combination of a show of
- gratitude appropriately to Joe Biden did
- you see so in their joint um event this
- week oh we should talk about that in the
- prescription drugs um it was interesting
- to watch President Biden next to kamla
- Harris having to stand there and she
- gave him you know so much credit and so
- 15:00
- much gave his due she did she really
- kind of oh by the way prescrition drugs
- that's another area in which the Biden
- Administration the Biden Harris
- Administration has kept prices or is now
- in the process of getting prices down
- using the bargaining power of Medicare
- this is something that you know Bernie
- Sanders was talking about years ago I
- know and finally we have Administration
- that is doing it and she's going to do
- even more of that yeah it was
- interesting that that's the first rally
- they came out again I mean we know that
- voters care about these things they care
- about the economy when you continue to
- look at the polls what they say matters
- most to them you know abortion is up
- there we know it but the economy matters
- and it's it's it it is the cost of
- living coming back again and again and
- again uh very practical very practical
- issue so I think that the first thing
- that happens at the convention is a huge
- show of gratitude toward Joe Biden and
- then we move to the coronation of Tim
- walls and then the big Thursday of the
- 16:01
- coronation of kamla Harris uh and
- there's going to be a lot of excitement
- I think the only thing that worries me
- frankly is the war in Gaza and and it
- worries you because it worries you
- and I'm worried yes I'm worried about
- the humanitarian cost obviously I've
- been worried sick about it uh but I am
- also worried politically uh this is you
- know I remember the 1968 Chicago
- convention I remember you know I was an
- anti-vietnam
- War protester I was not there at that
- time I was driving across country you
- told us that on a previous watch um but
- it was uh it it was in
- Chicago and it really did split the
- Democrats and the Democrats have never
- fully recovered from that split U and I
- think the war in Gaza U has a potential
- to do the same thing I I I think that
- 17:01
- they're trying very hard to avoid it but
- something like 30 delegates there are
- from States and from districts uh where
- there are a lot of people who are
- extremely upset about what's going on in
- Gaza and so we're going to see some of
- that right and justifiably so so it'll
- be interesting there'll probably be some
- protest outside we'll see if there's
- some shouting inside don't know and then
- these uncommitted delegates will see
- what they say and do right yeah that's
- right so it's those three but I'm not
- going to go you're not I'm
- not Oh I thought you were I thought you
- were flying out no no you you you're not
- going no I'm not going well I've been I
- was I was going to say you were at was
- it the 96 well was the the 88 you
- remember the 88 convention in Atlanta
- vividly yeah and Michael
- dakus uh Bill Clint gave the
- introductory speech when 32 minutes uh
- 18:00
- the the when the only Applause line
- during that Clinton speech introducing
- Michael D caucus was when Bill Clinton
- said in
- conclusion Hallelujah and then I was at
- the uh I think the
- 96 um and then I was at the I think we
- might even have a clip no should we do
- it no let's please let's take a look
- well the Comm look at it is ever vescent
- it is POS some journalist came up to me
- yesterday and said off the Record
- I love the way a journalist comes up to
- me and says off the Record said off the
- record I was in San Diego said that
- journalist and the difference between
- Republicans and Democratic conventions
- is at San Diego they tried to act
- festive and here they are festive yeah
- Donna Shala and I'm you're going to be
- hardpressed to beat this taught us the
- marara Mr secretary well there's my
- there's what I mean about festive huh
- you couldn't have got that at the de at
- the Republican convention what's the
- dance at the Republican convention uh I
- think it's the Twist from
- we shake it a baby anyway let's get this
- 19:01
- sound to something
- serious oh my God I'm shocked you don't
- want to go back the the Macarena I never
- did the Macarena you did I've see I feel
- like I've seen you Macarena maybe not at
- the convention not the conven after
- party yeah the after party um that was a
- goodie um so you're not going to go okay
- so you're not going to go I'm not going
- to go um anything else to discuss I
- think we've kind of covered it well I I
- think we did I um but but it's
- interesting that clip about the festive
- nature of the convention in 96 it was
- festive uh and certainly more festive
- than the Republicans but I think the
- contrast this year is even greater oh
- for sure because the Republican
- convention was
- so was so angry I mean there was anger
- and testosterone you know the kind of
- this year yeah this year uh and this
- coming Democratic Convention I think is
- 20:01
- just going to be uh upbeat I think that
- the the notion and that's what that's
- really what kamla Harris and Tim uh walz
- are are giving to the party and to uh
- young people and to women and to even
- some old codgers yeah old white men a
- lot of old codgers me it's a sense that
- politics doesn't have to be about anger
- it can be about Hope about the future uh
- about uh what we want for our country
- and ourselves right and not to be a
- pessimistic Patty but a lot of people
- are hurting so they we have to be a
- little tempered right I mean of course
- it's the politics of joy and it will
- there will be a feeling of elation there
- will be but it has to be measured but I
- think there's a connection Heather
- between the politics of Joy uh and uh
- the notion that we have the capacity to
- do things that we haven't done before um
- 21:01
- dealing with the problem of the poor and
- the working class and the stagnation of
- incomes for so many people dealing with
- uh food prices dealing with all of the
- problems the everyday problems that
- people have uh we are upbeat and we are
- uplifted because of our confidence and
- our ability to handle these issues and
- this is why I like having coffee with
- you cuz you've been around the block
- you've seen the ups and the Downs I've
- been around forever you still have hope
- I do I do I do and you do too do this
- and you do too and listen thank you for
- being with us uh be hopeful be festive
- and we'll see you next Saturday
- [Music]
| |